A Comparison of Physically Aggressive Behavior in Two VA Nursing Homes
Daniel Rudman M.D.1,
Luca Alverno M.D.1, and
Dale E. Mattson Ph.D.1
1 Medical College of Wisconsin, 5000 West National Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin 53295
Objective: To investigate an apparent difference in the prevalence of physically aggressive behavior in two Veterans Affairs (VA) nursing homes, the authors compared ratings by nurses of residents' assaultive behaviors at the beginning and end of two six-month periods in 1987 and 1991. Methods: The prevalence of assaultive behavior in each of three diagnostic subgroups (neurologic, psychiatric, and medical) at nursing homes A and B was determined using standardized biannual ratings of patients' behavior. Chi square analysis was used to compare prevalence rates and to compare the proportions of nonaggressive patients who were rated as aggressive at the end of each six-month period. Results: Nursing homes A and B were significantly different in the proportions of patients in the three subgroups; facility A had a greater percentage of neurologic and psychiatric patients, and facility B had a greater percentage of medical patients. Both in 1987 and in 1991, the prevalence of assaultive behavior in nursing home A in all three diagnostic subgroups was higher than that in nursing home B, usually by a statistically significant margin. A significantly higher proportion of nursing home A residents in each subgroup who were rated as nonaggressive at the beginning of the two periods were rated as aggressive at the end of each period. Conclusions: Further studies are needed to learn whether the substantial difference in assaultive behavior resulted from intrinsic characteristics of the facilities' populations or from the qualities of their environments.
Note:
The authors thank Ruth Hartmann, Ed.D., for valuable help in the preparation of this report. This work was supported by the Medical Research Service of the Department of Veterans Affairs.
